Check out my new book

Topics

Move Over Fish

Good news for those of us who don't eat fish! Although fish has been touted as a health food for the past 5 years, some folks are concerned about the level of mercury and other toxins (namely polychlorinated biphenals - or PCB's - and pesticides). Other factors such as cholesterol and homocysteine - which both contribute to atherosclerosis - are concerns for others who eschew fish. Then there are people like my husband, who find fish to taste, well, fishy.

A new study from the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (read abstract here) has found that Omega-3 fatty acids from plants may be just as efficient as those from fish. Researchers from the School of Medicine Health Policy and Practice in England examined the diets and fatty acid status of 14,422 men and women aged 39–78 years old. While they found fish-eaters consumed higher levels of Omega-3 fatty acids in their diet, non-fish eaters had similar levels of Omega-3 in their blood as those who consumed fish regularly.

The researchers conclude that if other studies have similar findings, "it could have implications for fish requirements". In other words, confirmed by further research, fish would be recommended less for its Omega-3 content.

For a little background on this subject, plant-based foods contain a fatty acid called alpha-linolenic acid (ALA) that has been widely debated for its rate of conversion into the Omega-3 fatty acids that are renown for preventing disease and boosting immunity. These fatty acids are known as DHA and EPA. Some studies show that ALA does convert efficiently into DHA and EPA, while others do not. This study falls into the latter, and I believe we will see more to verify this in the future.

3 Comments:

  1. Vegan ninja said...
    Hi Bronwyn, I am a bit confused about vegan and vegetarian diets. I have read your blog for about three years and know your position about these issues. Lately I have been reading other blogs, one specially got my attention, a girl that was vegan for about three years, turned back to eating meat because of serious health problems, like very important iron and B12 deficiencies. Her doctor told her meat is VERY important in the human diet, but in small quantities and that vegan and vegetarian health is a myth. What makes me think this may be true is that this girl had an extremely healthy diet. I would really like to hear your point of view, because I am almost vegan and wouldn’t like to jeopardize my health because of lack of information, and I know you are a nutrition specialist, with great knowledge on these topics. Thanks, your comments will be greatly appreciated.
    Bronwyn Schweigerdt said...
    That is a great question, Vegan Ninja! I've heard a handful of stories like this. Personally, I would not eat meat for iron or B12 reasons (iron deficiency is just as common among menstrating non-veg. women as vegetarians, and B12 is found fortified in lots of alternative milks and cereals).

    However, I am not opposed to eating small amounts of organic meat or eggs for other reasons. For example, I know a woman who stopped getting her period when she was a (raw) vegan. She introduced eggs and was able to get pregnant.

    On the other hand, there are MANY people throughout the world who live their entire lives vegan or vegetarian, and are extremely healthy.

    I would not agree with what this doctor said based on what I know, but I also believe if someone feels healthier consuming a small amount of animal protein they should listen to that.

    Hope this helps a little. Some great books to check out are The China Study (Campbell), and Healthy at 100 (Robbins).

    Hope this is helpful!
    Vegan ninja said...
    Thanks for your prompt answer! I will check the books you recommended. As you say, I will do what makes me feel healthier (eating vegan, that is) but still will get blood tests for iron, and other posible deficiencies periodically.

Post a Comment



Related Posts Widget for Blogs by LinkWithin

Search Beandiet

Loading...

About Me

My Photo
Bronwyn Schweigerdt
I am a speaker, nutrition instructor and author of Free to Eat: the Proven Recipe for Permanent Weight Loss. I have a Master's degree in nutrition from Tufts University.
View my complete profile